Winters wrote that oligarchy and democracy operate within a single system, and american politics is a daily display of their interplay. Democracies and oligarchies are not made by the nu. The greek citystate, or polis, is the most general association in the greek world, containing all other associations, such as families and trade associations. Examine the views of aristotle, thomas hobbes, john locke, john calhoun, and john dewey, on democracy. The varieties of the main types of constitution, especially democracy, oligarchy, and polity c. However, aristotle later observes that, at least in practice, aristocracy and polity are mixtures of the deviant regimes. Democracy is the authority of all citizens, while oligarchy is the authority of the wealthy people. Summary and analysis of aristotles politics all associations are formed with the aim of achieving some good. Democracy is the least bad because it is the most moderate iv, ii. Aristotle and xenophon on democracy and oligarchy aristotle. Raising the question of how equality should be secured, aristotle recommends a compromise between democracy and oligarchy, suggesting that sovereignty should be granted to whichever side has the greatest absolute amount of wealth.
What is the difference between oligarchy and democracy. Along with his teacher plato, aristotle is generally regarded as one of the most influential ancient thinkers in a number of philosophical fields, including political theory. The tyrannical man would represent tyranny, for example. Aristotles political theory stanford encyclopedia of. Pericles and aristotle on government mrcaseyhistory. In this video we examine modern democracy and whether it is an effective barrier to tyranny. On the one hand, evidence of democratic possibilities is undeniable. The meanzng of aristocracy in aristotles political thought. It is customary, however, to define polities those sorts of polities. While reading democracy and oligarchy by aristotle, i was a little confused at first. Frank, a democracy of distinction chicago and london, 2005, c. A treatise on government by aristotle translated from the greek of aristotle by william ellis, a. Keywords aristotle, oligarchy, democracy, plebeianism, inequality, harm.
Pdf in this essay instead of trying to deal with the dubious question whether aristotle is a democratic or an oligarchic thinker, i try to. For the same laws cannot be equally suited to all oligarchies or to all democracies, since there is certainly more than one form both of democracy and of oligarchy. Is the distinction aristotle made between monarchy. The unity of aristotle s theory of constitutions one of the most wellknown ideas in aristotle s politics is his division of political constitutions politeiai into three broad kinds, each with a good and a bad form. Aristotle and xenophon on democracy and oligarchy pdf the constitution of the athenians ascribed to xenophon the oratorthe politeia of the spartans by xenophonthe boeotian constitution from the oxyrhynchus. It is important to note that aristotle did not consider oligarchies and democracies as inherently bad. In aristotle s politics, he focuses much on the regimes of an oligarchy and of a democracy. Various theorists shared different views on democracy, some of whom are aristotle, tomas hobbes, john locke, john calhoun and john dewey. Plato also assigns a man to each of these regimes to illustrate what they stand for. They are aristocracy, timocracy, oligarchy, democracy, and tyranny. Aristotle lists, in order of preference, the good constitutions of monarchy, oligarchy j an d politeia th e las t of which is sai to b hi preferre term for wha mor thuc. Aristotle s the constitution of athens xenophons the politeia of the spartans the constitution of the athenians ascribed to xenophon the orator the boeotian constitution from the. The project gutenberg ebook of politics, by aristotle. Pdf in this study we examine the representation of income groups in two eulevel institutions, the council and the european parliament.
Article information, pdf download for aristotle and the problem of. For treatments that recognize, as the present paper does, the intentional, and therefore intensional see 3 below, aspects of aristotles conception of constitutional correctness, see w. Wherever men rule by reason of their wealth, whether they be few or many, that is an oligarchy, and where the poor rule, that is a democracy. Without any assumed connection to the recent events in europe and the us, these paragraphs on oligarchy and democracy resonate now as they did about 2,400 years ago. These five regimes progressively degenerate starting with aristocracy at the top and tyranny at the bottom. These conceptions of liberty and by extension democracy share the fundamental principle that all people are equal, regardless of wealth or merit. Oligarchy is a government in which a small group of people exercises control over everyone else with no input from the general populace.
According to aristotle, oligarchy, which he defined as rule by the wealthy few, was the least stable and hence least desirable form of government. The boeotian constitution, from the oxyrhynchus historian. Aristotle argued that oligarchies and democracies are the most common forms of government, with much in common except their allocation of power. Oligarchs were sufficiently few in number to easily collude to promote their private interests against the public interest. For the real difference between democracy and oligarchy is poverty and wealth. Sources of the democratic tradition primary source 10. Sometimes factional conflict is with a view to the regime in the sense that it will transform from one to the other, such as democracy to oligarchy and oligarchy to democracy. Pdf aristotles relevance to modern democratic theory. It is a confounding moment in american political history. Simply speaking, polity is a mixture of oligarchy and democracy. In aristotles political thought tspace university of toronto.
Aristotle thinks rulers should be those with property and. I feel he was all over the place when speaking in this writing because he talked about many different points and i felt as if i. Government, aristotle says, should be by those people with enough time on their hands to pursue virtue. Nov 14, 20 in aristotle s politics, he focuses much on the regimes of an oligarchy and of a democracy.
The real difference between democracy and oligarchy is poverty and wealth. Who rules lawful common good lawless private interest one monarchy tyranny few aristocracy oligarchy many polity democracy modern concept of democracy polity constitutional democracy dickerson and flanagans. Ancient greeks would not recognise our democracy theyd. In the ethics aristotle lists, in order of preference, the good constitutions of monarchy, oligarchy. In the process we look at two threats to democracy, a tyranny of. Socrates on oligarchy and democracy economic sociology and. The principles of oligarchy and democracy, and the nature of distributive justice d. Aristocracy, timocracy, oligarchy, democracy, and tyranny. Jun 03, 2016 what would aristotle have thought of modern liberal democracy. Democracy is a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or. Thefavoredreadingworks to unite books iii and v of the politics in an unfamiliar way, and it also uni. Simon johnson wrote that the reemergence of an american financial oligarchy is quite recent, a structure which he delineated as being the most advanced in the world. The structure and formation of some of the aristotelian writings, to which are added.
As such, the citystate must aim at achieving the highest good. Co first issue of this edition 1912 reprinted 1919, 1923, 1928 contents. In contrast with our modern notions of democracy, aristotle would have seen demokratia as denoting the rule of the demos or common people in their own interests. Jan 28, 1975 aristotle and xenophon on democracy and oligarchy book. In thepoliticsaristotle identifies four kinds of democracy and four kinds of oligarchy read online download pdf. Aristotle s distinctions among monarchy, oligarchy and democracy function as a kind of preliminary division of the subjectmatter. Oct 28, 2010 aristotle and xenophon on democracy and oligarchy j.
Activity based on aristotles views on equality, write a brief essay explaining why you believe guarantees of equality make government stronger. For aristotle, democracy is not the best form of government. At the age of 17, he went to athens to study at platos academy, where he remained for about 20. In aristotles politics, he focuses much on the regimes of an oligarchy and of a democracy. As is also true of oligarchy and monarchy, rule in a democracy is for and by the people named in the government type. Choose the type of government that you would like to represent in your cartoon. At the age of 17, he went to athens to study at platos academy, where he remained for about 20 years, as a student and then as a teacher. A thriving oligarchy in the richest and most politically developed nations implies a limited, rather than a sham, democracy. The constitution of the athenians, ascribed to xenophon the orator. Aristotle on legality and corruption 29 plato, in the republic, describes the contrast between the ideal and inferior states in terms of an imagined decay or destruction, using the word pthora 546a, the greek term later regularly latinised as corruptio. There also may be factional conflict concerning more or less, such as more or less oligarchic run or less or more or less democratic run. Democracies exists when the free and poor, being a majority, have authority to rule, and have an equal share in the city. Fortenbaugh, aristotles practical side leiden, 2006. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
It is important to recognize that oligarchy can operate without explicit coordination or cohesion among. What are the strengths and weaknesses each theorists views on this subject, in your opinion. Aristotle and modern representative government theories of elite democracy claim to show how representative. The unity of aristotles theory of constitutions is his. Aristotle and xenophon on democracy and oligarchy by john m. Also, aristotles political thinking is not separate from the ethical principles so he states that the government should be reflected in the. The promise of happiness through virtue made possible by the state aristotle, the western worlds first and perhaps greatest systematic thinker, emerged out of what historian thomas cahill refers to as the most wildly participatory democracy in history sailing the winedark sea. Of these, tyranny is the worst, says aristotle, then oligarchy. Aristotle was born at stagira, in macedonia, in 384 b. Oligarchy and democracy linnbenton community college. Create a comic strip that represents the leadership of. Make generalization what does aristotle say about the in. Jul 06, 2015 in book viii, socrates discusses with glaucon platos older brother various regimes. Ancient greeks would not recognise our democracy theyd see an oligarchy june 3, 2016 6.
1333 438 1512 16 1576 1178 794 879 303 674 140 1264 663 1315 75 1196 759 1376 880 468 468 423 1239 178 15 1368 124 952